Showing posts with label Alison Bechdel. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Alison Bechdel. Show all posts
Monday, December 23, 2013
no image


I often worry about the impact my stories will have on those that read them. I worry that the need to root myself into everything I write will alienate people who don't share any common experience or worldview. I worry by writing what I know, I will push away those that I don't.

This is especially tricky for me because in my private life I aim to be as inclusive as possible. I find myself harboring bigotry for the ignorant and for the hateful, but, besides that, I do everything I can to approach situations and people by seeking to understand before I condemn, if at all I should.

I've written before about the Bechdel test and how it's a good sort of cultural thermometer. In the same stroke, I've tried to paint a picture showing how such a test is ultimately ineffective, but that doesn't mean its ideas are useless. Stories with varied characters, whether of different sexes, beliefs, backgrounds, etc., are important for the sake of variety and because those are the stories that aid us in telling the truth. Of course, the truth, at least in a literary sense, is more about intention than it is about factuality, but I digress.

The Predicament
I've been making some great progress with a short story I've had in my head for some months now. The main character, a young girl, has surprised me more times than I can count, taking on a life of her own, as our creations so often do. The problem is that I find her world populated by many of the same types of characters; namely, they're big, scary men with  a bone to pick with my young antagonist. Even if they aren't of the big scary variety, they tend to be male.

So, I find myself wondering: am I doing myself and the story an injustice by not populating it with other female characters? Surely, in the instance of the world being the main villain, the sex of the minor antagonists is superfluous at best, but what does it say about my writer's mind, my thoughts about the roles of the sexes in general, that the villainous nomads are all male?

The Double-Edged Solution
I want variation of character in all of my stories, but this decidedly monotonous representation of minor characters has left me to wonder what the implications would be on a bigger scale. What if, in this instance and others, having female characters or male characters or straight characters simply doesn't suit the story? Maybe what my narrative needs is a uniform type of bad guy. Does it make the tale inherently weak if it has no place for diversity?

This is something I've taken to calling the double-edged solution; truly, I want to satisfy the need for good female characters in storytelling, but if it doesn't serve the story, should I push to fulfill these sorts of "equality requirements" just because? It seems that forcing anything creative to fit into any kind of mold is the best way to stifle that creativity.

It's something I've thought about for quite a long time, and I've yet to come up with the answer to the question. I think that more stories should be written to fulfill the Bechdel specs, but I'm torn by the idea that they should all have to.

What do you think, creative community?

--


Charles Hayward is a web writer, short story author and novelist, and a social/political activist interested in furthering the cause of humanity, the well-being of the environment, and improving the world in general. His work has been featured on Examiner.com,Unplug the Matrix, and on the Japanese culture-themed blog They Call Me An Egg.


Read more
Sunday, November 10, 2013
The Bechdel Test: Useful but Ultimately Ineffective

This week, Sweden began implementing a "Bechdel" rating system for all movies released in the country. By implementing a Bechdel-based rating system into all films released for the silver screen, Sweden hopes to bring gender equality to its film industry. While the attempt at pushing gender equality into film is laudable, at least in my opinion, it won't amount to much.

Source:http://bit.ly/1aMR6O1
What is the Bechdel Test?
The Bechdel test, according to Feminist Frequency, was invented by Allison Bechdel in 1985, when she featured the concept in her comic strip Dykes to Look Out For. The concept is simple; in order to meet standards of gender equality, each piece, be it film, novels, etc., must meet three criteria. First, the work must have at least two named women. Simple enough, right? Next, those women must, at some point in the narrative, talk with each other. Lastly, when they talk, it has to be about something other than a man.

Now, as I've said, the Bechdel standards are something that everyone should keep in mind. The fact is that an overwhelming majority of popular films, American and international, utterly fail this test. Strangely enough, Gone with the Wind, a film that features so many anti-equality themes, passes the test with flying colors.

Useful but Ultimately Ineffective
Saying that the Bechdel test is important would be an understatement, in so far as it can be used to open our eyes to the lack of good female-driven stories out there. The problem, especially with the recent decision by Sweden, is that it addresses a symptom instead of the cause. The fact is nobody is going to start writing gender-equal or female-centric pieces until they understand that those are interesting, important stories to tell.

It can't be, or shouldn't be, any surprise to see the staggering statistics around women's issues that are rooted in a fundamentally patriarchal upbringing. The Huffington Post reports that women still make 77 cents for every dollar their male counterparts make. Statistics from the Center for American Women and Politics at Rutgers show that a shocking 18.3% of the United States Congress, an average between the House's 17.9% and the Senate's 20%, are women. 18.3%! Pages of statistics and anecdotes could be drummed up here in support of the point, but the main idea is this: so long as fundamentally backward ideas and situations affecting the lives of women remain unchanged, no test for equality, Bechdel or otherwise, will mean a thing.

So, Where Do We Start?
The Bechdel test can be used as a social thermometer, a marker of how far things have come and where they are going, but if we want to actually make a change in the representations of women on the big screen, then we need to start educating people from childhood on what equality actually means. Teach little girls that it is perfectly fine to love their Disney Princesses but that life can't be lived waiting for prince charming to come and sweep you away. Teach our little boys that there is more to masculinity than being the guy kicking the door down, lightsaber in hand as they rush to save the princess. In general, show our children that, regardless of their role, e.g. gender, parent, wife, husband, that everyone deserves to have their voice heard; more specifically, we need to teach them that everybody has a story to tell. In doing so, we can improve real-world representations and opinions as well as those represented on screen.

What impact do you think the Bechdel test and the ratings systems it inspires can have?



Read more